Skip to content

← The archive

The Trust Label Is Live. The Disclosures Weren't.

A full investigation into W Social

A quick word before we start: I have written about W Social before. Four times now, in fact. (W. What's it Worth?, Hit By A Silver Bullet, W Social's Beta Is Live. The Problems Didn't Wait., and W Social Isn't New. It Isn't Truly European. It Isn't Even Theirs.)

I assumed the story would carry on at its usual pace: a quiet repository deletion here, an EC migration there. I did not expect it to acquire a certification body by November.

It did. This morning at 07:00 CET, an embargo lifted and Europe MédiaLab announced the first laureates of its new label, Trusted European Platforms (TEPs). I spent today pulling it apart.

A disclosure of my own, first: my account lives on Eurosky's PDS, this blog runs on Leaflet, an AT Protocol client on which I write, and I have been rude about W Social since January. Everything below is sourced, and on the Atmosphere you can check all of it yourself, by design.

What went out at seven this morning

Europe MédiaLab, formerly Fondation Euractiv, is a Brussels think-and-do-tank, a Belgian foundation of public interest headquartered in the Résidence Palace. Its Executive Chairman is Christophe Leclercq, the founder of the Euractiv media network.

At 07:00 today, the foundation announced the first nine laureates of its new label, "awarded by an independent Attribution Committee" of six experts, scored against three pillars and nine criteria. There are tiers:

  • National Champions: nebenan.de (part of Burda Media Group), gutefrage.net, Lidé (part of Seznam Media Group)
  • European Challengers: eYou Social, W Social, wedium, Monnett
  • Beginners: Bulle, Qwice

One fact about the nine, before anything else: all of them are closed source. Keep hold of that, because it is the most consistent thing on the entire list, and the rest of this post keeps colliding with it.

The timing was managed to the minute. A communication kit on the foundation's site, embargoed until 18/11/2026 at 07:00, hands laureates and committee members pre-written announcement templates so everyone's blog post goes out together.

There is nothing sinister about a comms kit; every launch has one. It is still worth watching this one work. By early afternoon, Romanian business outlets were carrying the eYou laureate story, quotes from the co-founder included (Business Review, Romania Insider). That is what a pre-packaged embargo is for.

Hold on to the phrase "independent Attribution Committee", because most of what follows turns on it.

The announcement quotes the committee chair, Luc Suykens, describing "an inclusive and non-competitive label". It quotes committee member Nancy Brito saying "verified trust turns European platforms into investable companies". Keep that second one in mind as well.

The committee, in full

The foundation's own Attribution Procedure page publishes the roster. The six voting members, listed with the affiliations the foundation itself prints:

  • Luc Suykens (chair), Union of Belgian Advertisers
  • Daniel Knapp, IAB Europe
  • Nancy Brito, Ground Capital, a venture firm investing in early-stage European startups
  • Clare Melford, Global Disinformation Index
  • Jenny Romano, The Newsroom
  • Emmanuel Tourpe, France Télévisions

The page notes that members "participate in personal capacity", which is an important and mostly fair caveat. These are real people with real expertise. Melford in particular has spent years doing genuinely difficult disinformation work, and I am not accusing any of the six of dishonesty.

Still, look at the composition. Two of the six belong to the advertising lobby. One is at a venture fund, one at an AI journalism startup, one at a public broadcaster, one at a disinformation index. Then notice two structural details the page prints quietly, at the bottom.

First: the committee is "supported by Europe MédiaLab Team without voting rights", and that support includes Christophe Leclercq, listed as Committee Secretary. The foundation's Executive Chairman sits inside the committee machinery.

Second: read the five-step procedure. The desk research, the pre-selection, the preliminary scoring and the assembly of the dossier the committee votes on are all performed, in the foundation's own words, by the Europe MédiaLab Team. So the independent committee votes on dossiers prepared by the staff of the man who founded the label, and its decisions are minuted by that same man as secretary.

Step 3 of the same procedure is worth quoting exactly, because it makes the conflict unavoidable on paper. In the pre-assessment, the Team must "request and verify private data shared by the organisation (governance, owners, management)". The procedure did not merely permit a check on who owns the applicants; the ownership check was mandatory. Whatever the dossier on W Social said about its owners, the team that wrote it is led by one of them. Either the dossier named him and nobody flagged it, or the process is not being run as published.

The foundation's own social accounts are more casual about who does this work than its procedure page is. A video it promoted on 12 November explains how the TEPs programme works, and introduces the presenter as "Aleks from the pre-selection team". That is Aleks Vangjelofski, Senior Manager for TEPs Strategy on the foundation's own team page, and committee Administrator on the attribution page. Pre-selection is done by staff. The staff say so themselves.

There is a third detail, and it is the most serious one. Daniel Knapp, committee member for IAB Europe, is also listed on Europe MédiaLab's own board (as "AB Europe", sic). The committee is meant to independently assess an award issued by a foundation. One of the six assessors sits on the awarding foundation's board. Whatever "independent" means in Brussels, it cannot mean that.

And the label's stated purpose keeps drifting back to advertising. The chair of the committee is the CEO of the Belgian advertisers' association. Another member is the chief economist of IAB Europe, the digital advertising trade body; in today's announcement he is quoted emphasising "that advertisers benefit from a wide choice of trusted platforms". The initiative's foundational text on the foundation's site is literally titled Trusted European Platforms: "democracy shield" replacing toxic networks, and it counts a €49 billion European social advertising market, more than 90% of it flowing abroad.

The lead initiator gets the last word on purpose, in his own announcement: the label, he says, "will help find partnerships with news media, raise funds, and, in due course, carry trust-based ads". A trust label for social platforms, staffed half by the people whose market it measures, that exists to sell advertising against the badge. It is all right there, in the press release, unashamed. The only thing missing from the press release is the rest of the story.

Follow the money

This is the part I spent longest on.

On 20 January 2026, W Social was announced at Davos: a Stockholm start-up led by CEO Anna Zeiter, co-founded with Ingmar Rentzhog, the Swedish entrepreneur behind the climate media company We Don't Have Time. The two had first met on a Zoom call on 31 October 2025. Twelve weeks from that first call to a Davos launch.

The staging deserves a mention of its own, because the launch venue was a fringe event on the margins of the World Economic Forum, described in exactly those words in the organisers' own upload (the video). t-online's correspondent watched Zeiter present against a screen reading "Something is broken", with Pink Floyd's Another Brick in the Wall playing in the room, to show off a product that was then a landing page: a world map with Europe circled as the blank spot, and a box asking for an invitation code (his report).

About that map, because it was the pitch. A world dotted with the big social networks by country of origin, a blank where Europe should be, and beneath it a box for your invitation code: the blank was the product. The quiet move was scoping. The map counted the handful of US giants, then read their absence as a census of the continent. Mastodon, built and run from Germany, was almost a decade old that January, and the Fediverse it anchors is thousands of community-run servers, many of them European. Europe had social networks. What they evidently lacked was a fringe event in Davos.

The white spot was already false on the protocol W Social forked. When heise introduced the start-up to German readers, the framing wrote itself: After Eurosky. The Dutch non-profit's account service, on Hetzner hardware in Germany, was taking signups. So was the long tail of independent operators. Tophhie Social, a community PDS created in September 2025, has since announced its own retirement in public, "Retiring on the 9th December 2026", support address included. Small European infrastructure lives and dies in the open, right down to the decommissioning notice. The map had to be scoped to the very top of the market to come out blank.

The scepticism started in the same week, and it did not start in the Fediverse. Four days after that presentation, a Dutch tech outlet ran the headline "W: Europe's answer to X that demands your passport", privacy critics and all (IO+). Ordinary tech desks were asking what mandatory identity verification would mean while the platform was still a world map. In November, an attribution committee came down on one side of that argument.

The frame outlived the launch week. The archived copies of wsocial.eu from those days are password-encrypted pages, and the only branded words on them are the greeting "Hi friend of Europe" (the archive). By February the gate was down and the credo was up: "We believe in the need for a global, trusted social media platform owned, run, and hosted in Europe" (February's archived copy). At the June beta launch in Brussels, Zeiter's pitch line was "We are giving away our data, our revenue, and our attention to foreign companies that give us, in return, content, but also disinformation" (EUobserver's transcript). A sentence like that only parses on a continent with no platforms of its own. In July, pressed on the American protocol underneath the product, she answered that "Europe needs an alternative right now, not only in 3 or 5 years", and named the arrangement "the best of both worlds" (Cybernews). The same Cybernews piece notes, in passing, that the protocol makes W interoperable with "other AT protocol-based platforms, such as EuroSky". Journalists keep noticing the rest of Europe through W's window. W's own materials never look out of it.

The name itself was part of the same pitch, and it was not subtle. Italian coverage of the launch confirms what the branding implied: the W stands for We, with two Vs for Values and Verified, and the founders also picked the letter, the piece reports, because it precedes X in the alphabet (Libero). The same article explains that the interface deliberately resembles X, so that users would not have to learn anything new.

The EUobserver transcript had already conceded as much, unprompted: asked what the app looks like, the answer was "Like X, basically" (the transcript). So the product pitching independence from American social media was named as a jab at one American social media company, skinned to feel like that company's app, and built on an American-born protocol underneath. The letter just before X is an odd place to declare independence.

Elena Rossini's deep dive into W Social's origins documents all of it, including a detail she lifts from SvD: Rentzhog's earlier venture, as Swedish press reported at the time, raised close to SEK 10 million in venture capital using Greta Thunberg's name without her knowledge.

The registry picture is mundane but clarifying. W Social AB, org.nr 559544-6690, is registered in Stockholm at a We Don't Have Time address, with Rentzhog chairing the board and We Don't Have Time holding roughly a quarter of the shares; the company's own figures, as recorded in May, put it at more than 750 investors from some 15 countries, and a team of around 25 (the same infrastructure analysis, which went through the filings). None of that is a scandal in itself. It is a normal way to start a company, and the founding money is on the record. But Step 3 of the attribution procedure made ownership a mandatory question, and nowhere in the label's launch materials did the answer appear.

In February 2026, Swedish Tech News recorded an early-stage round for the company behind W Social, W Social & friends AB: SEK 50 million. Read the investor list, because it is public and has been all year, and I want you to see who is on it: Anna Zeiter, Pär Nuder, Sandrine Dixson-Declève, Anders P Carlsson, Fredrik Strömholm, Christophe Leclercq, Johan Sundstrand, Jan-Allan Fredriksson, Ingmar Rentzhog, Erik Ringertz.

That is Christophe Leclercq: Executive Chairman of Europe MédiaLab, Committee Secretary of the TEPs label, and an investor in W Social.

And not just investor. In May, Rentzhog posted, straight from W Social's own PDS, about "our advisor @christopheleclercq.wsocial.eu" (the post, readable via Eurosky's mu.social mirror). The man who leads the organisation issuing the "trust" certification is an advisor to the company receiving it, and an investor in it.

The company's own website agrees, in brighter colours. Its "people behind W" page carries a card for Leclercq. Badge: "Advisory board member". Role: "Co-Founder Europe MédiaLab / EuroActiv". Bio line, as it stands today: "Trusted European Platforms (TEPs) Initiator" (archived on 17 June already carrying the card). So W Social markets the man who initiated the TEPs label as one of its own advisors, on a public page aimed at investors, and has done since at least June. The label, meanwhile, has never once returned the favour of mentioning it.

The advisory board list around him is worth reading too. The same page lists the founders and several names from that February investor list: Pär Nuder, a former Swedish finance minister; Sandrine Dixson-Declève of the Club of Rome; Erik Ringertz of Netlight. Around them sit Elizabeth Denham, the former UK Information Commissioner; Philipp Rösler, a former German Vice-Chancellor; Harvey Jang, chief privacy officer of Cisco; and Marc Placzek, former chief privacy officer of PayPal and now chief privacy officer of Tools for Humanity, the firm behind Sam Altman's Worldcoin iris-scan venture. It is a remarkable roster for a company whose app sits at 1.5 stars in a national app store.

One seat on that list deserves a paragraph of its own, because it rhymes with the passport. Placzek's employer, Tools for Humanity, is the company behind Worldcoin, the venture that pays people a crypto token to have their irises scanned, and the biometrics have drawn regulators wherever the orbs have landed. In December 2024, the Bavarian data protection authority ordered the project to delete iris-scan data it considered incompatible with the GDPR (Euronews). Spain's agency investigated the firm and issued a warning when it moved to resume activity in the country (the AEPD notice). Colombia's confirmed the immediate and permanent shutdown of the scanning operation on its territory (the SIC decision). A start-up that wanted Europeans' passports has on its advisory board the privacy chief of one of the most scrutinised biometric-identity projects on earth. Step 3 required the committee's staff to look inside W Social's governance. Whether anyone looked at what its advisors do for a living is not a question the published materials answer.

And one card on that page has since vanished. On 17 June 2026, between the others, W Social's site listed Louisa Specht-Riemenschneider, titled "German Federal Data Protection Commissioner", with the same advisory board member badge. That evening, a request under Germany's freedom-of-information law asked the BfDI for any records of its commissioner's function at W Social (the request). The authority replied on 24 June; the file's status reads "information not available"; and by 5 July her card was gone from the site. Neither the company nor the authority has said publicly why she was listed, or why the listing came down. A serving national data protection regulator on a passport-collecting start-up's advisory page is precisely the kind of fact a governance check exists to surface. Under TEPs procedure, somebody had to ask about the owners. You can read their answer where the badge used to be.

Now, in the interests of fairness, a disclosure about the disclosure. Leclercq did say all of this once, in public, in May, on W Social itself. His post from 12 May 2026 reads, in full relevant part:

Europe needs it OWN democracy infrastructure! Joining @Wsocial, as: 'W' stands for WE? Next: WIN! Worldwide?

Three days earlier he had posted: "Let's build and back #TEPs. Notably #Wsocial."

So the information was out there in fragments, and I am not claiming a cover-up operation. What I am pointing out is where those three facts never appeared: in the press materials launching the label at VivaTech in June, in the launch coverage, in today's award announcement, on the label's own website, or in any TEPs documentation.

A normal conflict-of-interest process puts that paragraph first, in bold, at the top. If you were a committee member relying on the published materials, or a journalist covering the launch, you would not know that the person whose team prepared the dossiers you voted on is, in his own words, an "impact investor" and an advisory board member at one of the winners. You would have been staffing an independent committee without knowing it, and taking minutes for him.

The whole thing came apart publicly this morning, again because Elena Rossini did the work. Her first post of the day set the theme: "Maybe the label 'Trusted European Platforms' should not be so trusted after all: every single platform they picked is closed source." An hour later she posted the correction that matters: the label's founder is "NOT ONLY an advisor to #WSocial, but also an INVESTOR".

The disclosure existed, technically, for six months. It just never existed anywhere a committee member, regulator or reader would naturally look. It existed where a founder's audience would see it, on the platform being labelled, next to the words "Next: WIN! Worldwide?"

The nine winners, in the cold light

The TEPs funnel is worth one more look. As the foundation has described its own pipeline, more than 600 platforms are listed on Rebuild.net, 45-plus were connected with, and 10 were pre-selected for TEPs. Six hundred went in, nine came out.

Here is what came out. nebenan.de is a German neighbourhood network with some 4.5 million users, acquired in the mid-2010s by the Burda Media Group, a German magazine conglomerate. Fine product, I'm told. It is also the definition of an incumbent: a "National Champion" that already had its championship.

gutefrage.net is a German question-and-answer site, launched in 2006, ad-financed, one of the oldest properties on the German web. Lidé is a discussion network belonging to Seznam, the Czech internet incumbent.

Call me old-fashioned, but when a panel of venture figures and ad-lobby economists certifies a 20-year-old, advertising-funded Q&A site and two legacy media conglomerates as "a new generation of European social media", the result looks more like an industry directory than a generation of anything.

The Challengers are seed-stage VC startups, no exceptions. eYou Social is a Bucharest startup that raised a €300K pre-seed in March, launched in May, and claims 130,000 users.

wedium is a Berlin platform built, per German press, by the Berlin advertising agency Glow, and launched out of beta in July. Monnett is a Luxembourg app from architect-turned-founder Christos Floros, backed by €655K in pre-seed money, running proprietary software.

The Beginners, Bulle and Qwice, are two French micro-startups. Bulle has a company called Shabon behind it and targets teenagers. Qwice is a French SAS incorporated in March 2021, hosting on OVHcloud.

Every one of the nine is closed source. Not one of them publishes the code that decides what a "trusted" post is worth.

And that is the sharpest pattern in the whole list. The laureates differ in age, size, funding, business model and country. The one thing all nine share, besides the badge, is a closed licence. If you want a single fact that predicts who made the laureate list and who did not, users, growth and European ownership all fail as tests. The licence is the one that works.

Now look at who got screened out somewhere between those 600 and those 9. Mastodon exists, and is the most credible open-source European social platform on the continent, and has been since 2016. Eurosky / mu exists: a non-profit, foundation-run, fully open-source European AT Protocol stack, whose identity platform was verified by the Digital Public Goods Alliance in October.

The label's own promotional copy, still live on its website today, name-drops mu.social and Mastodon alongside W Social, wedium, eYou and Monnett as the movement's characters. When the moment came to actually award trust marks, mu.social and Mastodon were gone from the list. Every name with an open licence behind it lost. Every name that spent 2026 raising venture rounds won.

The foundation describes its process as transparent, while noting that the "data involved are strictly confidential".

One more thing about the winners: they already knew each other. At the Nexus conference in Luxembourg in June, Anna Zeiter posted a photo of herself alongside Christos Floros, Leclercq, and Tine Larsen of Luxembourg's data-protection authority (CNPD). Two future laureates, the label's founder and a regulator, in one frame.

And several of them were in the founding club. In March, Luxembourg's Paperjam ran a guest column making the TEPs case, signed by what it called the Trusted European Platforms initiative (the column). The signatory list, printed at the foot of the page: Anna Zeiter, CEO of W Social; Christos Floros, founder of Monnett; Johannes and Nele Meissner of wedium; Clare Melford; Omri Preiss of Alliance4Europe; and Christophe Leclercq, described there as initiating the "Club for TEPs".

So three of today's nine laureates had names on the manifesto that proposed the label, months before it formally launched, and one of the committee's six voters was on it too. The same column promised the label would be awarded by "an independent body", in a process "comparable to... rating agencies for financial bonds". Read that back against the committee page, where the secretary of the process is an investor in one of the winners.

The signatory list holds one more wrinkle. Sherif Elsayed-Ali appears on it as "Co-Lead, Eurosky". Whatever a signature buys, Eurosky still did not make the laureate list.

The label officially launched, with W Social front and centre on stage, at a Reporters d'Espoirs event at VivaTech in June. That release said the first labels would be attributed in January 2027. The laureates landed in mid-November, weeks ahead of that timetable, with a comms kit, a pre-agreed embargo, and announcement templates for everyone involved.

The record being certified

The TEPs criteria ask the committee to score, among other things: "algorithmic transparency and recommender design", "interoperability, including portable identity and followers, as well as open protocols", "content integrity and provenance", and "user numbers with an acquisition plan".

Notice what the criteria never require: published source code. A platform can score full marks on "open protocols" while shipping every line of its client and moderation tooling as a trade secret. Nine of the nine laureates did exactly that.

Treat those as questions and put W Social, the European Challenger, in front of them.

Algorithmic transparency. W Social built on Bluesky's open-source code, launched on the AT Protocol in January, and then deleted its public repository in March, silently, without a deprecation notice (Elena broke the story; Tech Policy Press did the serious read). The client that decides what "Trust your feed" means is now closed source. What it scores on transparency is between the committee and its strictly confidential data.

User numbers. Per Rossini's October reporting, W Social's PDS held about 47,000 accounts, of which about 10,300 had completed the government-ID verification that the whole product hinges on, and about 4,289 had ever posted anything.

In June, its landing page displayed invented engagement numbers next to real posts: the site showed 22 comments under a post that had 1, and 184 under one that had 5. The true numbers were public all along, because W Social built on an open protocol, and independent developers caught it immediately. The tagline at the time was "Trust your feed".

In late June, per her ghost-town follow-up, a migration rate-limit throttled more than 3,000 accounts into a broken, invisible state for a week. Support stayed silent, the Play Store reviews fell to 1.5 stars, and the fix, per the developers Elena consulted, would have been a one-line request to a relay operator. There is no fixing what you won't acknowledge.

Portable identity and followers. I reported in August: no documented outbound migration path for ordinary users. Once accounts were anchored to a verified ID inside W Social, leaving was not a clean operation. The criterion that most directly names the AT Protocol's one foundational promise, the one the trust label copies into its rubric to sound serious, is the one W Social most conspicuously fails.

Data protection. In October, Elena documented that W Social was publishing the legal names, nationalities and approximate dates of birth of its verified users as public records on the open web: in plain text, downloadable as a CSV, collectable by anyone with an afternoon and a scripting language.

W Social's response: it is "public by design", consent was informed, and the linked W Identity app (the 13-step passport-and-selfie verification flow) is a separate legal entity. Elena also notes that the company's earlier public messaging gave users the impression that ID data would be immediately deleted and never linkable to their social profile.

The whole arrangement deserves holding against the initiative's own founding column, from March, which asked trustworthy platforms to avoid "micro-profiling, excessive data collection and the use of undeclared bots" (the column). W Social's beta opened in June with a passport-and-selfie flow for anyone who wanted to speak in public, on a promise that the ID check deletes your personal data right after the verification is done. Anonymity survives as the second-class tier: anonymous users "have limited activity" and "cannot participate in building public opinion", in Cybernews's summary of the interview. Nothing about posting text requires a passport. The person asking Europeans for theirs holds a doctorate in law and was eBay's chief privacy officer, per the infrastructure analysis and t-online's launch report.

All of this surfaced five weeks before today's announcement.

None of this took a source-code audit, only fourth-form arithmetic against public records, and the label certified it anyway. Either the committee was not told, in which case the "independent" process fails at the dossier stage, exactly where a conflicted secretary sits. Or it was told and scored around the record anyway, in which case the nine criteria are barely a filter. I know which answer I would bet on, and it is the one nobody has disclosed.

For completeness, the label's own monitoring rules are less forgiving than its launch was. Step 5 of the procedure lists revocation triggers: "change in ownership or control", "significant regulatory enforcement", "false or misleading information". June's invented engagement numbers count as false or misleading information in any plain reading. Under its own rules, the committee has written grounds to look again at what it certified this morning. Whether a strictly confidential process gets turned on a winner is now the only interesting question left about the TEPs label.

Two Europes, one protocol

One of the TEPs criteria scores "interoperability, including portable identity and followers, as well as open protocols". So the AT Protocol, the one this blog runs on, deserved the committee's particular attention. There are three European ways to build on it. Only one of them made the laureate list, and it is the one that fails the criterion at the only layer a badge can check: the source.

The first way is infrastructure. Eurosky, the stack my account lives on, is an initiative of Stichting Modal, a Dutch non-profit foundation seated in The Hague that grew out of the Free Our Feeds campaign. Its PDS runs on Hetzner hardware in Falkenstein, Germany. Accounts are free, open, and need no identity document. Its protocol components are developed with Igalia, under MIT licence. It calls itself infrastructure rather than a social network, and a Eurosky identity works with any AT Protocol client: Bluesky's own, Flashes, Tangled, Leaflet.

Those facts, and the architecture sketch above, come from a German-language infrastructure analysis published in May, the most careful public comparison of the two European AT Protocol ventures I have read. It went where the marketing does not. On the Atmosphere, hosting your own PDS is the cheap part. Its count, as of May: more than 1,640 PDS instances in the wild, two production AppViews, and the relay-and-AppView machinery that decides what a feed actually contains still sitting almost entirely with Bluesky in the United States.

Independence on this protocol comes down to who runs the parts that decide. Measured that way, the two ventures tell opposite stories. Eurosky publishes what it runs and what it does not run yet, and leans on Bluesky's PLC directory like everyone else, pending the announced handover to a Swiss non-profit. Open stacks disclose their dependencies. That is the entire difference being asked for.

W Social's materials, per the same analysis, document the PDS and stop. Nothing verifiable about a relay, nothing about an AppView, no documented licence for the Bluesky code it forked. Its product page sells the filing cabinet: "Your data is hosted by W on a Personal Data Server (PDS) in the EU, controlled by a European company." The quote covers the cabinet, and stops at its door. Swedish law and an EU PDS are real advantages over Bluesky, and I am not taking those away from anyone. But "your data is in Europe" answers a question about storage, and Cybernews tested the claim in July: its security researchers found it held for account information only, with posts and user content able to sync and host outside the EU, and the CEO pointing to an AppView server still being built (the interview). The feed machinery above the cabinet, which decides what "trust" amounts to in practice, remains the one part nobody outside the company can inspect.

Two receipts deepen the comparison, and both are in print. The initiative's founding column defined the European test as "ownership and sovereignty", "management and control based within the European Union", with "safeguards" against takeover from outside (the column). That is a paperwork test, and a Swedish AB passes it with Swedish filings. The same CEO, asked in July why build on the protocol at all, answered in growth terms: scale, by joining an existing pool of over 43 million users. The May analysis adds the history around the edges: a company that built on the open protocol without at first saying so, its developer endpoint giving away what the marketing would not confirm. Paperwork Europe, American plumbing, and the commons treated as a customer base.

The third way owns nothing at all, and is doing fine. Openvibe, from a Czech-founded team, stitches Mastodon, Bluesky, Threads and Nostr into a single client; it runs no network of its own, and announced $800,000 in early funding in January 2025, with Automattic among the backers (TechCrunch). Whether a client belongs in a platform label's scope is a fair question. What it demonstrates is the other open business on this protocol: treat the commons as a commons, and build on top of it.

Those are the three ways to be European on this protocol: publish the stack and its dependencies; build on the commons without owning it; or fork the commons, close the client and collect investors. The label went to the third one, and the other two are running today, in public, with no badge between them.

The plumbing is the telling part

I said at the start you could check all of this yourself, so here is me doing it, publicly. The identity facts below come from the PLC directory, the same directory everyone on the Atmosphere uses to say who they are.

Resolve @europemedialab.wsocial.eu, the account that posted this morning's announcement. Its DID is did:plc:piloe5vb3fi4647wh3r7nwyd, and its PLC record says its Personal Data Server is https://pds.wsocial.network.

Resolve @christopheleclercq.wsocial.eu, the founder and secretary: same PDS, https://pds.wsocial.network. Resolve Anna Zeiter's own @anna.wsocial.eu: same again.

So the organisation certifying W Social as trusted, and the man who founded the label, host their identities on the winner's own servers, in the same bucket as the CEO's account. The tenant is certifying its landlord.

And that is not Europe MédiaLab's only presence on the Atmosphere. They also hold accounts on Bluesky's shared PDS (@europemedialab.bsky.social) and on Eurosky (@europemedialab.eurosky.social), the platform everyone spent today noting the label had skipped. All three resolve, all three are theirs, as Logan Dupont noted under the announcement. In fact the announcement went out from all three of them, the Eurosky account included. So they know exactly where Eurosky is; posting there works fine. The only place Eurosky did not turn up was the laureate list they posted on it.

The replies under this morning's announcement are worth reading in full, because they are the community's real-time audit. Juan Lu: "So Eurosky is not even mentioned? Shame." Noz: "Not a single open platform. Wow." Moh Kohn, on Eurosky: "This is extremely embarrassing for you. Trust has to mean auditable open source code, open platforms, and a very high level of personal data protection."

W Social's defenders found the same threads. One explained the criticism as "envy and infighting", which is one way to describe reading a public investor list. His profile does not mention his employer, so Elena Rossini filled the gap: André Bäck is employed by W Social. Another defender argued that W's closed source "isn't exactly insecure, just more independent security", which is the entire philosophy of the TEPs laureate list, said out loud.

By evening, the official record from the winner's side had lengthened by exactly one item: the company account's milestone post, "Another milestone for W Social! W has been selected for the Trusted European Platforms programme!", boosted by its CEO. Nobody from W Social, Europe MédiaLab or the committee has answered a single question from today. And Leclercq, who joined W Social in May to help build Europe's democracy infrastructure, has not posted on it since 18 May.

One last observation. Everything in this post, the funding round, the advisorship, the identities, the deleted repo, the CSV, the throttling, the inflated metrics, is knowable because an open protocol makes it inspectable. W Social behaves as though none of it can be checked, on the one network where all of it can. The openness they treat as a chore is the only reason these receipts exist at all.

And there is an absurdity at the bottom of all this. The platforms whose code anyone can read, line by line, did not get the mark. The nine nobody can audit did. A label for "trusted European platforms" that sorts the open-versus-closed question that way round is measuring eligibility for something else, and the rest of this post is about what.

What would have qualified

The comparison the committee would have run, if the committee were what it says it is, is a 20-minute job.

Eurosky is a non-profit run by a foundation, in the open, on European infrastructure: PDS, relay, Jetstream, PLC directory mirror and AppView, all live and published, with mu, an app a person can actually use, on iOS and Android. In October its identity platform was verified by the Digital Public Goods Alliance as open source and run in the public interest.

It coordinates a position paper signed by dozens of European builders asking Brussels for exactly what the label claims to want: open protocols and portable accounts, no committee required. The community-run Rebuild movement, founded by Thomas Madsen-Mygdal with Margrethe Vestager as patron, gathered some 200 founders in Helsinki in August. Europe MédiaLab's own site borrows precisely that momentum, while awarding its trust marks to nobody from that room.

The raw numbers are comparable, by the way. Eurosky hosts on the order of 40,000 accounts. W Social's PDS holds about 47,000, of which about 4,289 have ever posted, because posting there means handing a passport to a company that then treats your identity as content. One of those two stacks got a trust mark this morning. It was the one with the 4,289 posters.

Against that, a committee chaired by the Belgian advertisers' association, with the ad trade body's chief economist and a venture partner in the seats, staffed by the label's founder as secretary, gave its mark to nine closed-source companies, including one its founder invested in and advises.

Britain has an expression for this that isn't safe for a blog about European digital sovereignty, so instead, the read: the €49 billion is not leaking out of Europe because the open-source options aren't certified. Europe MédiaLab, by its own account, prompted a European Commission scoping study into the market in the same period, and the foundation's own supporters, from Jourova to Lamy, appear in today's release vouching for the importance of European platforms.

Lamy, at least, was always going to. He wrote the op-ed that proposed the TEPs label in the first place, alongside Leclercq, in November 2025: Europe: Building Trusted Platforms to Defend Democracy, which asked for the label to be "awarded by independent experts" and put the Airbus, Galileo and Mistral parallels to work. When today's release quotes him endorsing the finished product, it is quoting its own co-author.

Genuinely: Europe does need European platforms. It needs them the way it needed GDPR, not the way it needed the Eurozone's credit-rating agencies. A certification body that can't state its own founder's conflicts in the first line of its own launch communications is, at best, an expensive way to allocate prestige.

And the money underneath this label is at least partly public. Europe MédiaLab is supported, in its own words, by "contracts or grants from European institutions, philanthropic foundations, corporate sponsors, and private donors". Today's laureates were picked with that money, behind a seal marked strictly confidential.

The fix

I said last time I don't want to be the guy who just says no. There is a version of this label worth having, and it takes about four changes:

  1. Disclose. Every financial, advisory and employment relationship between the founding team, the pre-selection staff, the committee, and every applicant. In the announcement. Not on a W Social account, in May, in passing.
  2. Recuse. Leclercq steps back from the TEPs label entirely, secretary seat included, for as long as he holds investments in or advisory roles at any European social platform, which by his own description is the plan.
  3. Publish. The scoring, per criterion, per laureate. If the process is "transparent" then it can survive a page of numbers, and if it can't, it was never transparent, just confidential.
  4. Require the source. No platform gets a "Trusted" mark whose client code and moderation tooling aren't published and auditable. A trust mark you can't check is just a sticker.

A disclosure you can read in the first paragraph of the announcement, a repository anyone can audit: that is trust that can be checked. Nine logos in a curated grid, awarded by a committee whose secretary invested in one of the winners, is a portfolio with a ceremony attached.

I'm still on Eurosky. You can check.

Comments

Checking AT Protocol sign-in…

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this post.